Lesson 1 of 6
Choose a question worth answering
Before asking an agent to tackle a research problem, ask who would care about the answer and what it would tell them. Revisit those questions when the first results come in. A calculation can become feasible long after specialists know what answer to expect.
Matthew Schwartz used BootLoops to test how well neutral biodiversity theory explained changes in a Panamanian forest. The ecologist James O’Dwyer told him that ecologists already knew the theory could not keep up with real forests. He suggested subtracting the neutral prediction and using what remained to study differences between species. That changed the question they put to the data.
Robert Lipshitz chose a question about Khovanov local equivalence groups that interested him, involved algebra he could check line by line, and had seemed too marginal for a graduate student to spend time on. He still leaves open whether the new algebraic structure has consequences for knots. His account gives a reason to pursue a modest question when the work becomes feasible and a reason to be precise about what answering it would establish.