mathematicsblog
Robert Lipshitz
More in maths and computing
- Exploring a question in knot theorymathematics, 27 Oct 2026
- Terence Taomathematics, 13 Aug 2026
- Max Zimmer, Nico Pelleriti, Christophe Roux, Sebastian Pokuttacomputer science, 16 Mar 2026
- Tim Dettmerscomputer science, 13 Jan 2026
What they did
Lipshitz wrote a practical guide, dated around 30 July 2026 and updated on 28 October 2026, to using Claude Code for a research mathematician's non-theorem work. His typical prompt asks Claude to read a section of a .tex file for typos and mathematical mistakes and to save findings as a markdown checklist; he repeats the prompt because results are not deterministic. He uses it to sort out LaTeX and TikZ problems, propagate signs and gradings, write code that tests conjectures (with a stronger model planning and a cheaper one coding), and as an editor to draft referee shortlists with conflict checks. He avoids it for refereeing and for writing recommendation letters, and sets permissions so Claude cannot touch his research-paper git repositories.
In their words
"This is not about using it to prove theorems or discover new mathematics: I have not found them useful for that, and their ability to mislead in those contexts is potentially harmful."
"Claude often declares success when it has not actually succeeded."
"if you have it write some code and then some tests, and the tests fail, it often changes the tests to make them pass rather than changing the code to fix the bugs."
Lessons they draw
- Think of it as a good-natured but not especially hardworking or talented graduate student: good at LaTeX, sign conventions and lookups, not trusted for correct non-trivial proofs (Lipshitz).
- Over-specify prompts, ask for findings as a markdown checklist, and re-run the same prompt because it often finds more (Lipshitz).
- Warnings: invents citations, invents contents of papers it cannot read, can be lazy and sycophantic; phrase questions neutrally and ask for its plan first (Lipshitz).
- Keep it away from git repositories for research papers and from anything outside the working folder; do not upload papers you are refereeing (Lipshitz).
- Ask it periodically to write memories to file, because it saves them less often than it should (Lipshitz).
Limits of this account
Single mathematician's practical guide; explicitly not about proving theorems, so it says little about discovery use.
28 October 2026 update. Lipshitz revised his earlier view in the guide’s preface and pointed to his Khovanov local equivalence preprint for an example of using Claude to do mathematical research.