# William Baude

- Researcher: William Baude
- Role: Law professor (writes as one on the Divided Argument blog; title not stated on the page)
- Field: law (constitutional law, standing)
- Tools: Claude Code ("Fable 5.1", Max effort); Pangram AI-text detector
- Published: 2026-09-25
- Source: https://blog.dividedargument.com/p/claude-generated-legal-scholarship
- Latest flagship models when written: Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6 Sol. Latest now: Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6.1 Sol.

## What they did

Baude opened Claude Code, tuned to "Fable 5.1" at Max effort, and asked it to expand the previous day's blog post into a law review article with no further input. He had written the idea himself and the model drew on his earlier writing on standing. By lunchtime it had produced a 505KB PDF draft titled "Aesthetic Standing First Principles". He published the draft and his assessment, and added that an AI-text detector scored it 48% AI-generated.

## In their words

> "I don't think it is as good as the piece I would have written"

> "I thought the results were quite good. Better, frankly, than I expected."

> "When I ran the article through Pangram, it came back as only 48% AI-generated."

## Lessons they draw

- The idea and the framing were his; the experiment tests drafting from an existing argument, not originating one (Baude).
- A single prompt with no iteration still gave a usable draft; he expects back-and-forth would improve it (Baude).
- He does not claim to agree with all of the generated piece (Baude).

## Limits of this account

One experiment, one prompt. The prompt text appears only as an image, so it is not recorded here. The model name is as written on the page. The post says nothing about citation checking of the draft. A commenter on the page questioned the detector score; Baude reports it without endorsing it.
